| Year | Class | 136 Weight Class Champion | Score | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1969 | Steve Agnew Brainerd |
|||
| 1968 | Ken Mara Notre Dame |
|||
| 1967 | Doug Johns Brainerd |
|||
| 1966 | Gordon Connell Brainerd |
|||
| 1965 | John Farr Red Bank |
|||
| 1964 | John Farr Red Bank |
|||
| 1963 | David Moss Red Bank |
|||
| 1962 | Buck Wood Sewanee Military |
|||
| 1961 | George Farr Red Bank |